Dr Hazel Cameroon castigates suggested Mnangagwa presidency

Dr Hazel Cameroon castigates suggested Mnangagwa presidency
Published: 17 November 2017 | by Dr Hazel Cameroon

source: www.theconversation.com/why-a-mnangagwa-presidency-would-not-be-a-new-beginning-for-zimbabwe


Despite claims to the contrary by the Zimbabwean military spokesperson Major General Sibusiso Moyo, Zimbabwe is in the throes of its first coup d’état since independence in 1980. Robert Mugabe, the only head of state the country has known in its 37-year existence, is today under house arrest, and the former vice president, Emmerson Mnangagwa, who has long aspired to succeed Mugabe, has returned to Zimbabwe from South Africa, after having fled on November 6.


It appears that Mugabe’s decision to sack Mnangagwa – possibly at the behest of his wife, Grace Mugabe – may turn out to have been his last major decision as president.


These events have provoked much interest and anticipation around the world, and not least from Zimbabwe’s former colonial master, the UK. The British foreign secretary, Boris Johnson, stated in the House of Commons on November 15 that:


this House will remember the brutal litany of [Mugabe’s] 37 years in office; the elections he rigged and stole; the murder and torture of his opponents … Authoritarian rule, whether in Zimbabwe or anywhere else, should have no place in Africa.


Johnson also warned against any transition “from one unelected tyrant to the next”.

For the past three years, the British government has displayed an interest in reengaging with Zimbabwe. It is an open secret that Britain’s re-engagement identified Mnangagwa as the candidate they could best work with. When the current British ambassador in Harare, Catriona Laing, took up her post in September 2014, her mission was to “rebuild bridges and ensure that re-engagement succeeds to facilitate Mnangagwa’s rise to power”. In September 2017, it was reported that British diplomats were working to secure a Mnangagwa succession “with a US$2 billion economic bail-out underwriting the project”.


According to diplomats with direct knowledge of succession discussions surrounding the rebuilding of post-Mugabe Zimbabwe, Laing has not wavered in her support for Mnangagwa to succeed Mugabe and, since Mnangagwa’s hasty retreat to Pretoria on November 6, it seems the British have worked tirelessly behind the scenes to facilitate Mnangagwa’s unhindered return to Zimbabwe and installation as president of the ZanuPF government. It has been reported that plans to take over the country by force have been in place for some time – and that Mnangagwa was instrumental in those plans
There are unconfirmed reports that a new post-Mugabe deal is under discussion. Under its terms, Mnangagwa would lead a transitional government in Zimbabwe with the support of other political parties leading to full elections in five years’ time. There are suggestions that Mnangagwa has the backing of the Chinese – who recently met with the commander of the coup, General Constantino Chiwenga – while the South African government allowed him to return to Zimbabwe unimpeded on November 15.
So it seems the end of the Mugabe era has come. But one has to ask whether a Mnangagwa presidency would really be a new beginning.


The Crocodile’s credentials


Mnangagwa, known as The Crocodile, has throughout the history of Zimbabwe been complicit in the manipulation of the ZANU-PF election process by promoting violence, intimidation and repression as well as illegal administrative strategies to ensure ZANU-PF election success. He has also long faced allegations of corruption and diamond looting in both Zimbabwe and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.


In 2012, the NGO Global Witness released an investigative report that revealed how ZANU-PF and the military elite used the proceeds from looted diamonds to fund human rights abuses. The report specifically points to the complicit conduct of Mnangagwa and his ally Chiwenga.


Mnangagwa has also been accused of playing a pivotal role in the Matabeleland Massacres of 1982-1987. In January 1983, Mugabe launched a massive security clampdown on the unarmed citizens of the Matabeleland region, violence that was both politically and ethnically motivated. This episode of relentless and persistent state-orchestrated violence, known as Gukurahundi, was perpetrated by an elite army unit known as the Fifth Brigade. It is estimated that 20,000 people were massacred and many hundreds of thousands of others tortured, beaten or raped. Mnangagwa has denied involvement and has blamed the army.


On March 4, 1983, at a rally held not far from Lupane in Matabeleland, Mnangagwa publicly conflated being a citizen of Matabeleland with being a political dissident. According to news reports at the time, he told his audience the government had “an option” of “burning down … all the villages infected with dissidents”, saying “the campaign against dissidents can only succeed if the infrastructure which nurtures them is destroyed”.


He described dissidents as “cockroaches” and the Fifth Brigade as “DDT” brought in to “eradicate” them. In short, he made it clear that the destruction of the civilian population of Matabeleland was part of a deliberate state policy – and the very next day came the country’s worst massacre yet, on the banks of the Ciwale river, when 62 people were killed.


The crimes against humanity perpetrated in Matabeleland left hundreds of thousands traumatised – many still don’t know where their loved ones are buried. The victims of Gukurahundi are deeply divided, stigmatised and discriminated against. Their plight will go unaddressed if the person who succeeds Mugabe is himself responsible for appalling political crimes and harms to which millions of Zimbabweans have been subjected.


If Zimbabwe is to step back from the brink of state failure, it must find a way to address the Mugabe regime’s crimes, including Mnangagwa’s role in Gukurahundi. At the very least, Zimbabwe’s neighbours and the international community alike must stand in the way of those responsible for state-sponsored atrocities and corruption that have been the hallmark of Mugabe’s government for 37 years obtaining or maintaining positions in the post-Mugabe government of Zimbabwe.


In order to promote a stable, secure and reconciled Zimbabwe, the crimes of the regime of Mugabe must be addressed, and this includes Mnangagwa’s crimes and his role in Gukurahundi. The British government seems to have other plans.


- Source:theconversation, dr Hazel Carmeroon, published by umthwakazireview.com

Comments

Latest News

Mzilikazi II's spokesperson warns UK over trade deals that involve Mat
February 13, 2018 Our Ref: Mthw 0213180900 Ms. Elena Wi...
1893 MHRRM says No to UK's planned deportations of Matebele Genocide v
The 1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restoration Movement (1893 MHRRM...
King Mzilikazi II visits elderly in Old Phumula
   The elders appreciated having to spend qual...
Mnangagwa delusional on Mugabe never made a mistake
Yes, he never made any mistake because everything he did was inten...
MLF rebukes Masuku for playing sycophancy politics with Genocide
Gukurahundi Genocide issues have brought unity among the peoples o...

Polls

What is the greatest threat to Mthwakazi nation

73%
4%
6%
15%
Of Mnangangwa, Davos and Matebele “Gukurahundi” Genocide Denialism
The 1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restoration Movement (1893 MHRRM) ...
Mzilikazi II spokesperson clarifies misleading Statement on Mzilikazi
The office of King Mzilikazi II wishes to make some clarifications...
1893 MHRRM: Who are We and Who is Who?
1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restoration Movement (1893 MHRRM): W...
Isikhulumeli sikaMzilikazi II sikhupha umbiko ngemvoxovoxo ephuthumayo
Mthwakazi omuhle ,lina bondlela zimhlophe, lingabe linjani kum...
1893 MHRRM calls for another UK Matebele Genocide Demo
The 1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restoration Movement’s (18...
King Mzilikazi II visits Ngozi Mine
The King for some time has wanted to visit the Ngozi mine commun...
Umbiko ngesethekeli sakwaZulu
Sokulombiko ophuthumayo lapha. Isethekeli sethu sakwaZulu aka...
King Mzilikazi II condemns arrest and torture of Matebeleland 8
King Mzilikazi II condemns and protests strongly the arrest and be...
Mnangagwa Bring Back Our Youths: 1893 MHRRM
The 1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restoration Movement condemns in...
uMbiko oMkhulu: uSomlomo kaKing Goodwill Zwelithini wethekelela uMthwa
  Mthwakazi omuhle ,lina bondlela zimhlophe mnyaka om...
Zanu PF's ministry of National Healing and Reconciliation is a mockery
When Zanu PF created the ministry during the GNU era, it appeared ...
1893 MHRRM RSA and UK Demos a success
This statement, from the 1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restorati...
King Mzilikazi Christmas message
King’s Christmas Message, 2017 It is that time of the year when ...
1893 MHRRM ups its Gukurahundi Genocide Demos Campaign in London and J
Gratitude and many thanksFirst and foremost, we extend our grati...
Transitional Government of Tamil Elam Human Rights Conference Report
“Tamil’s Human Rights Conference on the World Human Rights D...
Mutsvanga throwing stones while in a glass house
If one lives in a glass house, he/she must not throw stones. This ...
1893 MHRRM expresses solidarity with Tamils, intensifies Demo campaign
The 1893 Mthwakazi Human Rights Restoration Movement (1893 MH...
Office of HRM King Mzilikazi II statement on the King issue
PRESS STATEMENT FROM THE OFFICE OF HRM KING MZILIKAZI I...
1893 MHRRM calls for Demo in London on 23rd December 2017
  For Immediate Press Release   1893 ca...
Chronicling the Revolutionary Works of King Mzilikazi II
CHRONICLING THE WORKS OF A REVOLUTIONARY KING: AN UPDATE ON THE RE...
A gang of crooks staging a coup De'tat: MLF
A GANG OF CROOKS STAGING A COUP D’ETAT: CLAIM TO CLEANSE ZANU ...
Restoration of Matebeleland Kingdom: A position Paper
MATABELELAND KINGDOM POSITION PAPER: CASE FOR THE RESTORATION OF T...
Of Mnangagwa, Matebele Genocide and Diamond blood money
The political crisis in Zimbabwe is far from over without the two ...
Mthwakazi National Party Lives On!
Mthwakazi National Party Lives On!   In April 201...
MLO lambasts Gukurahundists who attacked Marabini
Tribal attack on internationally acclaimed jazz musician from Mata...
MLF's proposes Matebeleland exit Bill
IN PURSUIT OF OUR IDEALS,WE SUBMIT:   MTHWAKAZI EXIT (M...
Mzilikazi II replaces th BASC flag with Mthwakazi Flag
King Mzilikazi II replaces the British South African Flag whi...
Izinduna zakwaZulu zixhasa uMzilikazi II emsebenzini weNxwala
Inkosi uMzilikazi wesibili wenza uMhlangano koBulawayo.Mhlaka 18 N...
Matebeleland:On the Dialectics at standstill; Why We Must Not Celebrat
On the Dialectics at standstill; Why We Must Not Celebrate! It rem...
Mugabe in a cage, No to Presidency of Butcher of Matebeleland:MLF
          &n...