Manchester United Fans must shut up: Van Gaal is in charge

Manchester United Fans must shut up: Van Gaal is in charge
Published: 22 February 2015 | by Gary Neville



The time has come for Manchester United fans – me included – to let go of the Sir Alex Ferguson reign and stop judging this new era by former glories. The style of play and the names have changed, but the one person not confused by the team’s development will be Louis van Gaal.

 

I’ve never been a manager, but I personally believe in attacking football, with a high tempo. If United were committed to protecting that style of play at all costs they should have appointed a manager with those beliefs. But there was no way Van Gaal was going to come to Manchester United and adopt somebody else’s philosophy.

 

It’s a bit like breaking up with a partner of 26 years and wanting the new person to be the same as the old one. They – we – are going to have to let go. The idea of referencing Ferguson or saying "It’s not the Manchester United way" at every turn stylistically is not going to take Manchester United anywhere.

 

 

Personally I would like them to play at a higher tempo. I would also like them to press high against inferior opposition, but I've come to the conclusion this isn't the Van Gaal way. It's what I believe in, what United have previously believed in and not what is in front of us now. I also think most of the new signings should be performing at a higher level.

But, if you had told me as a fan that we would be third in the league at this point, in the quarter-finals of the FA Cup and on a run of one defeat in 19 games, I would have snapped your hand off.

 

Again: it’s about moving on, which is hard because we were married to a way of playing and a leader who dominated English football for 20 of his 26 years. Now, we are in a completely different period. We are not comparing like for like.

 

Seven years ago I found myself giggling with a group of mates through a business leadership speech in which the guru used four words to describe change. They were “form, storm, norm, perform.” It didn’t resonate me with me until I started thinking about United’s current condition.

 

The idea was this. When you “form” you bring in new parties. The storm is the chaos point. Norm means the new structure, bedding in. Perform speaks for itself. Coming out of the Ferguson era, United certainly saw the storm. But the norm has yet to fully establish itself, post-Ferguson and David Gill.

 

Many United fans feel confused between thinking ‘the pace is slow, we’re not playing the way we used to,’ and ‘hang on a minute, we’ve lost one game in 19, we’re third in the League and in the quarter-finals of the FA Cup.’

 

Definitive opinions remain elusive. You can say momentarily: good performance, bad performance; this player played well, this one played badly. But we are moving out of that hazy period, to a 14-day spell in March when opinions can harden. Arsenal in the FA Cup and Tottenham (home) and Liverpool (away) in the league. To reach an FA Cup semi-final and pick up four league points in those games would put United within striking range of ending the season on a high. Those results go wrong, and this could be a baptism of fire for Louis Van Gaal in his first season.

 

My biggest area of confusion is the following. Watching the team who finished third last season, Chelsea, it was quite apparent where the missing pieces were. They needed a creative midfielder to make the difference in tight games and a centre-forward who could finish the chances off. Two distinct areas where they needed to improve.

 

United are currently third in the Premier League and I don't have the same clarity . Even now I struggle to locate the precise deficiencies. I find myself looking at five or six areas. Van Gaal’s work will be judged not by whether he can take United back into the Champions League this season but whether he can ultimately regain the English title. The Premier League is the benchmark.

 

I believe he will complete phase one: win a trophy and return to the Champions League. But to win the Premier League in the next two seasons he has to win the recruitment battle. In the last two campaigns United have spent £280m and recouped £54m. Chelsea have spent £313m but recouped £190m and brought in better players.

So, post Ferguson and Gill, Chelsea are definitely trading better than United. With the Juan Cuadrado signing Chelsea spent £24m and let Andre Schurrle go for something similar. United will need to be equally shrewd, and not simply buy off-the-shelf players for £40m and find they don't fit.

 

It seems to me that, pre-season, part of the recruitment was based on playing three at the back, with Rojo, Blind and Shaw coming in, with another part based on 4-3-3, with Di Maria and Herrera. At the moment the squad is unbalanced. Until the system is settled it’s hard to identify the players needed to make it work.

In a diamond system, for example, you need a very good No 10 who is going to score goals two very mobile forwards and energetic wide midfielders. In a 4-3-3, you need excellent wingers or wide forwards that can score goals. Playing three at the back you need two excellent wing backs. This is the conundrum at the moment. What style of play are United recruiting for?

 

These questions will be at the forefront of Van Gaal’s mind. And he knows he has to get this next wave of additions right. The summer, after the World Cup, and this January window arrived too quickly. By May he should know exactly how he wants to shape things.


Is he happy with Mata, Fellaini, Herrera, Falcao? All have been left out for long periods and all been given chances. Will David de Gea stay? What will happen with RVP? Depending on those decisions, he could find himself in the necessary position of wanting another batch of signings at a very high cost. I suspect he will be planning for a three-year stay and will push for players that can have an immediate impact.

 

I know he needs to strengthen but I’m not totally sure where or when. While United fans – me included – are unsure, the one person I guarantee won't be is Van Gaal because he is so sure of himself. I bet he can’t believe the current fuss. He will be relaxed, confident and pleased with a run of one defeat in 19.

 

This idea that United are lucky is wrong. Luck expires in an unbeaten run after three or four games. One defeat in 19 is not luck. Then again some of the big signings of the last 18 months are still well below their peak. They are not performing anywhere near full tilt. That’s a concern. In the next two or three months those star names have to perform or will find themselves under pressure.

 

Rooney is always central to these discussions, and seeing him go back to centre-forward last Monday at Preston tells me that the Van Persie-Falcao centre-forward experiment has probably ended. I’m not saying you will never see them again as a duo but it doesn't seem to work.

 

There is a particular movement that tells a story. When the ball goes out to Shaw or Valencia in the advanced full-back area, those two forwards in a split-striker system need to make a ‘corner run’, in between centre-back and full-back: first, to give a forward-passing option to Valencia or Shaw, and second to stretch the defence and open space in midfield.

 

Both those players – Van Persie and Falcao – are sometimes unable or unwilling to make those runs. Inevitably the ball then gets passed backwards. I think this can be directly linked to the lack of movement into wide areas from United’s strikers. This small change of movements would give more purpose to United’s play.

 

In this current system, then, Rooney is a better bet at centre-forward. If Van Persie and Falcao are going to play as a pair, you would need to play with wide players who would service them. They are both box players who lack mobility and blistering pace.

 

So here we are still in that storm period. And I am among those who have watched United thinking – this is a bit slow. Yet there is a transition going on, with the manager, who has a different way of playing to that of Sir Alex Ferguson.

 

How is it different? Van Gaal likes more controlled possession. Sir Alex liked possession too, but his big words were “tempo and risk.” He used those words so often in our changing room: "I want tempo and rhythm in our passing." Get the ball moving quickly.

If we were ever two or three up then he would be happy for controlled possession .Van Gaal is happy to shift the ball side to side relentlessly from minute one, not risk as much in possession and work openings whereas under Ferguson their was a greater intent to take risks until the game was won.

 

There are people who called Barcelona boring to watch with constant possession. Van Gaal is more inclined to want this type of game and we can be sure he won't change his way.

Had any other manager responded to Sam Allardyce’s “long-ball United” remark by turning up to a press conference with pages of stats, you might say they were cracking up. Whilst it was probably a mistake, a misjudgment, my experience of sitting down with Van Gaal earlier in the season tells me he will have produced those figures and facts to attempt to teach people.

 

I can imagine him sitting in his office saying: "I will cure them of their ignorance." He has managed at Ajax, Bayern Munich and Barcelona. Replying to Allardyce, he will not have been flustered. In his view he will have set out to educate the uneducated people about how football should be played.

 

His absolute confidence will have led him to think: ‘I will transform all your opinions, so you start thinking the way I think.’ I laughed when I heard people saying he’s cracking up. This was nothing like the Rafa Benitez incident, when the then Liverpool manager produced his sheath of “facts” about United. Benitez was under pressure, challenging for the title.

 

It's too early to pass the ultimate judgment on Van Gaal but we can have confidence that he has been down this road with huge clubs before. I always think of the very last question I asked Van Gaal in the interview I did for the Telegraph at the start of the season. “Will you win the league within three years?” He replied: “Yes, of course.”


- Source: The Telegraph

Latest News

Uloyiko's Press Release on Zimbabwean Threats
When we were starting this project, we knew that we will gain a lo...
Mthwakazi yet to gain her Independence: MLF
  INTRODUCTION The 18th of April every year...
1893 Mthwakazi Restoration Movement beefs up its International Board
 This comes as a way of an update to the membership ...
Ngeso LoKhozi on Mthwakazi's Right to Self-Determination and Secession
Ngeso Lo Khozi -  The Right to Self-determination and the R...
It is time to Restore and Rebuild izwe laboKhokho bethu
When 1980 came, people in the then Rhodesia were filled wit...

Polls

What is the greatest threat to Mthwakazi nation

71%
5%
7%
16%
1893 Mthwakazi Restoration Movement Releases its Flier
  The 1893 Mthwakazi Restoration Movement: Put...
MLF calls for defiance strategies for Restoration
INTRODUCTIONThe ever-coming echoes of RESTORATION as seen from the...
Stateless Matebele to be affected by anti-alien World immigration poli
After failing to get jobs in the Zimbabwe labour market where peop...
uLoyiko's SYO thanks Mthwakazi, Media and the public
Siphesakhe Youth Organisation (SYO) would like to thank all the ...
HRM King Mzilikazi II's Powerful and Inspirational Speech on uMthontis
25TH MARCH 2017UMTHONTISO FESTIVAL (INKONZO YOKUCHINSA LOKUBONGA...
uHRM King Mzilikazi II ukhokhela inxwala
Lamhlanje iNkosi uMzilikazi ll ivule yasungula umkhosi kaMthw...
Gukurahundists Tsvangirai and Mujuru can not amnesty other Gukurahundi
MLO was shocked to note that while MDC T leader, Morgan Tsvang...
MLF presented part of this speech at Loyiko's Event at the Market Thea
MTHWAKAZI LIBERATION FRONT ...
The 1893 Restoration Movement releases names of its Top International
          Afte...
1893 Matebeleland Restoration Movement Goes Public
  1893 Speech that was meant for uLoyiko Event ...
Mthwakazi College releases flyer and Mthwakazi Modules information
Dear Editor,Due to immense challenges of putting together a single...
Adopting Socialism and Communism was adopting a culture of Goats: Gudu
  IN DEFENSE OF THE MTHWAKAZI RESTORATION PHILOSOP...
Paul Siwela road-maps MLO's Matebeleland Restoration Agenda
Under the direction and authority of Matebeleland Liberation Organisa...
uMzilikazi II ukhuthaza uMthwakazi ukuthi atshiyane lokweZimbabwe
Phelandaba-umthwakazireview.com uthola umbiko wokuthi u-HRM K...
Mthwakazi United FC 2016 Annual Report
MTHWAKAZI UNITED FOOTBALL CLUB: ANNUAL REPORT: 2016 FOOTBALL ...
uLoyiko ups the ante on Demo, condemns Mugabe for Gukurahundi Genocide
South Africa’s Human Rights Day, 21st March, is fast a...
Mugabe's birthday Bash was a show of arrogance
INTRODUCTIONOnce again and for the umpteenth time, The Zimbabwean Pres...
Paul Siwela long predicted a bedroom coup in Mugabe's Zimbabwe
Before Jabulani Sibanda screamed, “bedroom coup!", Cde Paul Siwela...
The Unending Quest for Mthwakazi: A Nation without a State
THE UNDENDING QUEST FOR MTHWAKAZI: A NATION WITHOUT A STATEINKUNZI SER...
SA Xenophobic attacks: Interview with uLoyiko's Yanga Mhluzi
Yesterday 24th February 2017 saw widespread demonstrations in South Af...
MLF responds to Marxist-Leninist-Maoist Mabhena over Chief Khayisa and
IN DEFENCE OF THE MTHWAKAZI RESTORATION PHILOSOPHYOPEN LETTER TO A MR ...
uHRM Stanley Raphael Khumalo ukhuthaza umanyano phakathi kweSizwe sika
Njube- Izakhamizi zeNjube bezibuthene zithe gwaqa eNjube zizohlafu...
MLF condemns reburials and accuses MRP of tempering with Gukurahundi e
COLLUSION OF THE MRP WITH ZANU PF IN TAMPERING AND HIDING GUKURAHUNDI ...
Ngeso Lo Khozi: MRP's Zimbabwe Election Aftermath Possibilities
A couple of weeks back Mthwakazi Republic Party announced that they wi...
MLF rubbishes MRP's participation in Zimbabwean elections
WHY MTHWAKAZI LIBERATION FRONT (MLF)  CANNOT PARTICIPATE IN THE E...
uLoyiko condemns Mugabe's upcoming macabre and Gothic Birthday Bash in
uLoyiko theatre activists once again take this opportunity to exte...
Witch Mugabe's Gukurahundi Genocide Birthday Bash in Matopo: MLO
Like witches that choose graves of their victims as sites for cele...
Loyiko welcomes CIA Gukurahundi files, ups volume on 380 Degrees Demo
This comes as a way of an update to the people of Matebeleland...
HRM King Mzilikazi II writes to the Chair of Inkundla yamaKhumalo, Rev
27th January, 2017 Rev. Bruce Khumalo The Chairman, Inkundla...
Loyiko kickstarts its 380 Degrees Imbizo Demo on Gukurahundi Genocide
Please visit Loyiko’s 380 Degrees Imbizo Demo on GoFundMe and k...